The Strange Double Shooting At Aubrey Landing


About two miles northeast of Parker Dam in Arizona and about seventy-five feet beneath the waters of Lake Havasu lies the few remains of the little settlement called Aubrey Landing, sometimes called Aubrey City. It lies at the mouth of the Bill Williams River in southern Mohave County, Arizona. The town was founded before 1865 and was abandoned sometime after 1886. It’s important for the reader to know a little about Aubrey Landing in order for them to appreciate the events that lead up to the mysterious shooting that took place there in 1872.
 
The first real construction for the town of Aubrey Landing began sometime before 1865 during the Civil War in Arizona. The unknown founder named the river settlement after Francois Xavier Aubrey, a famous American pioneer from a decade earlier.
 
Aubrey was already important to trade along the Colorado River only a year after Arizona became a Territory in 1863.  The city at its busiest boasted 50 frontier-style buildings and a population entirely dependent on the freighting of supplies by steam boats and wagons to and from gold, silver, and copper mines in the region.  It was named for Francis Zavier Aubrey, a Canadian freighter, herder and rider noted for taking wagons, flocks, and himself rapidly and safely over long, unfriendly western routes. 
 
The town was ideally located but in 1865, a break in copper left the town almost deserted but enough people stayed, prompting a post office establishment in 1866. Little had changed though by 1878, the town never grew to the size anticipated by the owners. The town consisted of the usual mining camp structures, as well as a hotel, saloon and a general store. The town supported a small population for almost ten years more. In 1886 the post office closed and the town soon after. Freight and supplies landed at Aubrey from the steam ships along the Colorado River and then made their way to nearby mines such as the McCracken.
 
By 1878 the sights of Aubrey Landing were few but varied. In addition to the assorted piles of copper ore and slag left from the smelting furnaces, there was a combination post office, hotel, store, and saloon under one roof, and an old ship's cabin where W. J. Hardy, an agent for Colorado Steam Navigation Company, resided. Aubrey Landing supported a small number of people for nearly a decade longer. As the mining towns dwindled, so did Aubrey until there was no one left.
 
The story about the mysterious shooting begins in early October. It was still plenty hot and most people in and around at that time were ready for the heat to break. It seems that the double shooting that took place actually wasn’t in Aubrey Landing itself but just a little outside the city. A number of men had been playing cards in the hotel/saloon/store one evening. By one in the morning, everyone at the table had consumed copious amounts of whisky and all rational thinking had long since been lost.
 
Up until midnight, winning hands had been pretty evenly divided between the various players at the table but by one AM, two of the players were consistently winning all the hands. These two winners just happened to be from one of the steam ships that had unloaded earlier in the day. With all common sense severely wiped out by the previous hours of drinking, the loosing players began making comments about “cheating”, referring to the two winning players.
 
Because of the comments, the two winning steam boat hands and indicated they were going to leave the game and that they weren’t looking for trouble. Not something losers like to hear. As tempers heated up and accusations escalated, it looked like real trouble was about to erupt. Had it not been for the intervention of the establishment proprietor and a few of his employees, the situation certainly would have escalated into a gun fight on the spot. Kicking everyone out for the night, the proprietor closed up for the night thinking everything would blow over by morning.
 
Unfortunately for the two steam boat hand the situation didn’t blow over. According to the story, some time in the night while the two men were returning to their boat they were shot, killed and robbed of their winnings. Now ambushes and shooting were not uncommon by any sense of the word but these killing were unusually brutal. Both victims had been shot multiple times and each had had their heads literally smashed in so bad that they were almost unrecognizable. Of course, initially suspicion fell on the other members of the previous evenings game but each of the other game players had a solid alibi for the time frame concerned.
 
What had everyone puzzled was the fact that when the bullet wounds were counted on the two victims, they totaled up to over fifteen shots and not a soul in the little settlement could recall hearing any gun shots that night. The two victims were found just a little over a quarter of a mile out of town. Had anyone been shooting that close to town, someone certainly would have heard it. The whole incident wasn’t adding up to those looking into the shooting. Something strange was going on but no one could figure out the “What”, “Where” or “How” of the whole situation.
 
A dead body in hot weather isn’t a good thing so within twenty-four hours both victims had been laid to their rest with the mystery of their deaths still unsolved. Suspicions and rumors about the identity of the culprits ran through the town for the next week or so but by the end of October, the incident had become just another of the many mysterious deaths that took place in that time of Arizona’s history. Formal law enforcement was pretty scarce and had not the incident become a bit of local legend, the whole matter would probably been lost in history for all time.

More interesting stories can be found in The Tales From The Files Of The Arizona Prospector.